Dead Battery at End of Snow Run|General 4x4 Discussion|Forum|Gold Hills Posse 4x4

Don't Forget, meetings have moved to our new location @ Mark and Monica's Family Pizza, 4751 Manzanita Ave., Carmichael, CA 95608!

Forum
Avatar
Please consider registering
Guest
Advanced Search
Forum Scope


Match



Forum Options



Minimum search word length is 3 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters
message
Dead Battery at End of Snow Run
March 7, 2017
11:59 am
Avatar
kris_olof
El Dorado
Moderator

Club Trailmaster
Forum Posts: 1225
Member Since:
March 13, 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Went to start the Jeep at the end of the snow run and battery was dead. Not click-click-click, but dead, everything off.  Got a pull down the hill from Jeff and tried to bump start it the whole time to no-avail.  Borrowed some jumper cables and tried to jump it.  2 minutes connected and the light under the hood still wasn't illuminated.  I then pulled the leads off of Jeff's truck and touched them together to see if my battery had any juice.  The cables did have a slight arc but it was super faint.  I then put the leads back onto Jeff's truck and the light under the hood came on.  A couple of minutes more and we had the starter clicking.  This was enough juice to allow us to hill start it and then the Jeep ran fine.  

Initially I thought the battery had failed.  I have had cells fail in the past and this was similar.  Voltage on the drive home never made it much above 12 and never all the way to 14 where is should be.  I put a trickle charger on the battery over 2 days and tested the battery.  Full charge and over 800 amps, hmm.  So my battery was low but too low to turn on the ECU, prime the fuel pump, and charge the coil? Well yes.  Unlike a carbureted engine, all of those items are controlled by the PCM which has a low voltage cutoff.  I was unable to trigger my compressor which is wired not to need ignition.  But the compressor is triggered by relays and they have a minimum voltage to trigger.  

Ok so my battery was just dead, why?  I left my CB on but I always do that on day runs and I've even left my lights on once all day at work without issue.  Maybe there was a short somewhere or a terminal is loose? Nothing obvious.  At this point I decided to check the trouble codes.  I wasn't holding out much hope because I have an intermittent O2 sensor code that has been around a while.  Plug it in and i get the typical P0057 but there is also a P2503.  "Low charging voltage".  Great, alternator dead.  Go to pull it off and the charging cable nut is finger tight, problem found.  Pull the alternator anyway and have it tested, no problems.

So at some point my alternator charging cable came loose at the alternator, arcing caused the computer to stop charging and throw a code but my existing emissions code prevented me from noticing anything new on the dash.  I was basically driving on mostly battery voltage for who knows how long and it happened to cross over the critical minimum voltage at the top of the hill while parked.  Bouncing on the way back down the hill must have been just enough of to cause the cable to re-connect intermittently to keep the battery charged enough to get home.  

Thankfully I have a deep cycle so battery life hasn't been shortened too much.  I just replaced the batteries in my diesel so Im not looking forward to buying another battery for a while.

Lessons learned:

-Jeff really is the club tow truck

-Batteries are expensive

-Electrical issues are a pain

-Buy mopar O2 sensors so you can actually use your check engine light

March 7, 2017
12:58 pm
Avatar
Jeff_R
Meadow Vista
Member

Club Member
Forum Posts: 2014
Member Since:
July 14, 2016
sp_UserOnlineSmall Online

Kris, glad that's all it was. And the other lesson learned that you mentioned later that day is to not be the last one to start your rig. I'm glad Jeff B was still there to help you.

Jeff and Kathy Root

March 7, 2017
1:08 pm
Avatar
Gregulator
Member

Club Member
Forum Posts: 3113
Member Since:
September 3, 2008
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

So I don't need to return my battery now?

Um...what?

March 7, 2017
1:33 pm
Avatar
kris_olof
El Dorado
Moderator

Club Trailmaster
Forum Posts: 1225
Member Since:
March 13, 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Gregulator said
So I don't need to return my battery now?  

Better safe than sorry, i will trade you for an OEM one. grin

March 7, 2017
1:53 pm
Avatar
Gilbert & Betty
El Dorado Hills
Member

Club Member
Forum Posts: 1446
Member Since:
February 26, 2014
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Wow glad to hear that ended well Kris. I guess from now on before we all leave we should make sure everyone is good to "go home"  But seriously I'm glad all ended well. 

March 7, 2017
4:14 pm
Avatar
Josh
Member

Club Member
Forum Posts: 1630
Member Since:
January 19, 2011
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Interesting story Kris. Glad you made it back. 

What deep cycle battery do you run? 

Semper Fi

March 7, 2017
5:14 pm
Avatar
Guy and Lynda
Member

Club Member
Forum Posts: 1447
Member Since:
August 17, 2014
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

That's interesting Kris.  Thank goodness Jeff B was there and helped and he let us know what was happening so we hung out and waited.  It's all part of the "not leaving anyone out there" policy we have.  So cool.  

And btw, this is the 2nd time some kind of drama happened to you because you were the last to leave.  You go first on the next run!

March 7, 2017
6:27 pm
Avatar
kris_olof
El Dorado
Moderator

Club Trailmaster
Forum Posts: 1225
Member Since:
March 13, 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Josh said
Interesting story Kris. Glad you made it back. 

What deep cycle battery do you run?   

Sears branded odyssey.  Based on the load test no outwardly visible impact to drawing it down so low.  We shall see how the next winching session goes. 

March 7, 2017
6:32 pm
Avatar
kris_olof
El Dorado
Moderator

Club Trailmaster
Forum Posts: 1225
Member Since:
March 13, 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Guy and Lynda said

  You go first on the next run!  

You will forgive me if I dont trust your post.

proof.pngImage Enlarger

sp_PlupAttachments Attachments
March 7, 2017
7:57 pm
Avatar
Josh
Member

Club Member
Forum Posts: 1630
Member Since:
January 19, 2011
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

kris_olof said

Sears branded odyssey. 

Thanks Kris. I'm in need of a new battery for my truck. F250. Would you buy the odyssey again? Just curious. I've never used the Odyssey brand. 

Semper Fi

March 8, 2017
9:50 am
Avatar
kris_olof
El Dorado
Moderator

Club Trailmaster
Forum Posts: 1225
Member Since:
March 13, 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Josh said

Thanks Kris. I'm in need of a new battery for my truck. F250. Would you buy the odyssey again? Just curious. I've never used the Odyssey brand.   

For my diesel or my daily driver, no way an AGM is worth it.  Costco has the most painless pro-rated warranty and probably the best price, and AAA has same warranty with free delivery and replacement for $5-10 more per battery than costco.  Batteries like to crap out on me when I am out and about so being able to call and have AAA deliver and replace it anywhere (there is pavement) is super convenient. 

For me AMG is wheeling rig only.  AGM batteries like the Optima and Odyssey are great but pricey.  With the added stress of a winch, I think a deep cycle AGM is justified.  That said, if I ever add a second battery tray and isolator system to the Jeep I will switch to costco deep cycle.  I would rather have 2 batteries that might not last as long than only having 1 battery.  (also 2 deep cycle traditional batteries is about the same cost or cheaper than the deep cycle AGM options)

March 8, 2017
5:43 pm
Avatar
Guy and Lynda
Member

Club Member
Forum Posts: 1447
Member Since:
August 17, 2014
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

kris_olof said

Guy and Lynda said

  You go first on the next run!  

You will forgive me if I dont trust your post.

proof.pngImage Enlarger  

Holy moly!  Well this is the counter to the jinx  angelgrinbeerbeergiftflowergirlbeerdancehuglaughinglovewinkclapbeerbeerbeer

March 8, 2017
7:06 pm
Avatar
k-jeep
Parts Unknown
Admin
Forum Posts: 2288
Member Since:
January 20, 2009
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Gregulator said
So I don't need to return my battery now?  

Do you have a Sears Platinum? They didn't have them for the 2012+ JK when I bought my Odyssey.

Kevin

March 9, 2017
9:43 am
Avatar
Gregulator
Member

Club Member
Forum Posts: 3113
Member Since:
September 3, 2008
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Yes, Sears Platinum for me.  Based on Kris' recommendation and that I couldn't find an odyssey in stock anywhere.

Um...what?

Forum Timezone: America/Los_Angeles
Most Users Ever Online: 582
Currently Online: Jeff_R
Guest(s) 9
Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)
Top Posters:
JohnDF: 9521
Fred: 3609
Gregulator: 3113
Jeff_R: 2014
RobD: 1721
Josh: 1630
Tom: 1465
Guy and Lynda: 1447
Gilbert & Betty: 1446
Justin: 1416
Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 12
Members: 145
Moderators: 16
Admins: 2
Forum Stats:
Groups: 5
Forums: 24
Topics: 4474
Posts: 68716
Members Birthdays
sp_BirthdayIcon
Today: None
Upcoming: Jeff_R, 2013JKUR, Robert & Amber, HaZaRdZoNe